The Old Mill Creamery
Restored 1830s mill dairy; house ice cream, bottled milk, farm treats; classic day-off dessert stop.
Susky Says
John Nolt and his family make the ice cream and bottled milk at Old Mill Creamery with milk from their own dairy farm, and they restored a historic mill to do it. Take a country drive and taste the farm in every scoop.
Been here?
We keep this guide honest by fixing it when it's wrong. If the hours changed, the place closed, or we got something backwards, tell us. It takes a minute.
Also in Mifflinburg
Charity thrift with clothes, furniture and housewares. Sales fund hunger and homelessness programs. 3% fee on credit cards, none on cash or debit.
Mural by Emily Gaugler next to Pelican's SnoBalls on the Rail Trail. Scan the QR code and the flowers, clouds and butterfly start moving on your phone.
Former Moose Lodge; public by reservation; BYOB beer/wine; multi-event parties.